Scottish Witch Trials: Sorcery or Superstition?

Published on
21 October 2025
|
Written by
Laurie Knight

“By the pricking of my thumbs, something wicked this way comes.”
It’s an immortal line written in a time of witches.It was first recited to James the VI of Scotland, later James I of England,in the first performance of Macbeth. This took placea meredecade after his own encounter with the witch Agnes Sampsonin East Lothian.It’s easy enough to see, isn’t it? A terrible storm, a series of terrible storms, have delayed and curtailed your voyagetoreturn with your bride from Norway – where they talk with some concern of witches.Somebody must be toblame,somebody must be using witchcraft to undermine his desires.Itcouldn’tsimply be badluck ora naturalhappening,James was arepresentative of Godinvested with The Divine Right of Kings.Somebody must have been out to get The King.Somebody must be in league with The Devil.

The Witch: Agnes Simpson

Agnes Simpson was sometimes referred to as the Wise Woman of Keith, but wisdom is oft mistaken for witchcraft in a time wheresuperstition rules over rationality in the national consciousness.A widow with surviving children, Agnes worked as a midwife and a healer in her community.
Agnes Sampsonwasarrested,interrogatedand tortured in aprotractedfashion. Accountsstatethat she resisteda most painful torture of head compression for over an hour until the “Devil’s Mark” was foundand she confessed. Surely there is no otherreasonwhya woman might resistbefore breaking down in the face of pain, torment, and the abrupt loss of dignity.
The accused was brought before the King for final confirmation, beforelater being taken tothegallowsshe shared with many other witches at Castle Hill.
It was in this climate that Shakespeare wrote of witches, when men were believed to be led astray by the Devil, and something wicked did indeed come across Scotland.This is just one of the tales of witches we share on our Scottish Witch Trials Tour.

What Makes A Witch?

The truth is that spotting witches is harder than you might think. Obvious magic is sadly lacking today as it must have been hundreds of years ago.With that in mind, and conjured pots of gold orfountains of youthsofew and far between, onehas towonder how do we spot a witch?Is it by a certainnumberof warts on a chin orbeing a little cantankerous? Perhaps living alone or being a woman with too many opinions? What about cats?If we took a moment to think about it, a great many witches look like a great many modern women, don’t they?The truth is that spotting witches is harder than you might think. Obvious magic is sadly lacking today as it must have been hundreds of years ago.With that in mind, and conjured pots of gold orfountains of youthsofew and far between, onehas towonder how do we spot a witch?Is it by a certainnumberof warts on a chin orbeing a little cantankerous? Perhaps living alone or being a woman with too many opinions? What about cats?If we took a moment to think about it, a great many witches look like a great many modern women, don’t they?It is no coincidence that peaks in witch trials cameat times of political unrest. Be that the schism between Catholicism and Protestantism in the Reformation,at the changing of monarchs, or in the case of the spike around 1650 the shift in power away from the crown entirely.

It seems that witch finding is as much a social ill as a supernatural one. Add in superstition, a need to explain poor luck, and a little bit of good old neighbourly conflictand the climate was ripe for a century of witches between1590 and 1690. Full figures have never been known, with estimates ranging between 2,500 and 3,500 put to death in total for witchcraft.

Repeal and Apology for Scottish Witches

By the time the 1700s came around, witch trials were already falling out of favour. A dark and difficult period in British history wascoming to a close, and with it many of the reasons to scapegoatanyone irregular – particularly if they happened to be female.This coincided with a populace which wasmore and morequestioning their blind faith and instead tried to apply the values ofThe Enlightenmentin their undertakings.
The Enlightenment was an intellectual and cultural movement that flourished in Scotland roughly between the late 1600s and 1830. Centered mainly in Edinburgh and Glasgow, it was marked by extraordinary advances in philosophy, science, economics, medicine, education, and the arts.Key figures included David Hume, Adam Smith, Adam Ferguson, Francis Hutcheson, and James Hutton, among others. They emphasized reason, empirical observation, human progress, and social reform, shaping modern disciplines such as economics, geology, and moral philosophy.The movement’s impact extended far beyond Scotland, influencing the American and French Enlightenments and helping to lay the groundwork for modern Western thought and liberal democracy.

The last British witch executed was Janet HorneinDornoch;with neighbours claiming the Devil hadshod her daughter to ride like a pony, leaving the girl lame. On the face of itthis is a sad case of superstition and ignorance over disability. Both were convicted and sentenced to death, but the daughter is known to have escaped.
Prosecutions had already been shying away from capital punishment for some time, but this 1727 trial was the last of its kind. Less than ten years later the Witchcraft Act would be repealed in Scotland as well as the rest of the UK.While representing oneself as a fortune teller remained illegal, the charge carried only the penalty of a year imprisonment rather than the death penalty.
It is striking that within living memory, 63 years after a woman was burned alive in Dornochtown square, Burnswrotehis own epic poem on witchcraft as well as the follies of man. But despite the fanciful imagery of witches dancing in the old kirk, it is as much a warning abouttall tales told after too much drink.Scotland, and much of Europe, was turning away from superstition and instead applying the reasoning of The Enlightenment to their world view:

In a testament to how far we’ve come, in 2022 Nicola Sturgeon MSP apologised for the persecution and execution of supposed witches across Scotland. It is no small thing that 450 years after the likely misogynistic response to Mary Queen of Scots that an apology has been given by the Scotland’s first female First Minister for this “injustice of a colossal scale”.On our tours this autumn, we continue to celebrate the victims involved, acknowledge the horror of a different age, and continue stepping forward away from persecution and towards an ever more enlightened age. Please join us on our Scottish Witch Trials Tour, running Thursday to Sunday until November 2nd.If you enjoyed this blog, you may enjoy the Witches Trail in Fife. Additionally, if you believe a family member has been affected by the Scottish Witch Trials, there is an excellent resource available from Edinburgh University.